polly miller-insap


NAME: Nathan Gazin



Burned alive for witchcraft, her ghostly flame still burns to this date. She curses the very road that her colonial cabin once resided. She was sent to her demise after a prolonged drought left the farmland infertile and the livestock famished and dead. Accusations of witchcraft were placed upon her. The widowed farm girl was locked and boarded in her small home while natives set it a blaze. Her smoldering corpse was placed in an unmarked grave soon to be forgotten. In an attempt to lift the plague full curse that lays upon this darkened country road, its residence renamed it after her damned soul…. “Polly Miller”.


For More Information About:
This Website

The Mohawk Valley

5 responses to “POLLY MILLER”

  1. Jimbob says:

    Oldest (and also the lamest) tale in the book. You didn’t even include the part about the chair sitting in the road!! Also, fakest fucking shit ever, hahahaha.

  2. Charles Miller says:

    To Jim Bob,
    Welcome to the world of story telling. You’ve clearly heard of, and regarded this historic tale or else you wouldn’t have felt obligated to; 1. Search for this topic. 2. Comment your opinion. 3. Re-iterate your version.
    Versions of this story will change as time goes on… Possibly, by the time your old enough to vote…the story may change again.

  3. Thomas Backus says:

    I grew up on Polly Miller road and The truth is in the believer . I have seen many strange things in the exact place where her house sat !! I don’t think It is just coincidence that thing happen there !! My Parents actually owned the land until they sold it to my uncle William Robotham in 1982. Their house was built right across the road from the site that Polly Millers house was burned down.I seen things and I am convinced that there is spirits in this area !!

  4. Steven Nelson says:

    No I’ve seen her with my eyes it’s true, not kidding.

  5. Joe Plunkett says:

    Alright, here is the deal… I’m not going to drop names besides Thomas Backus because he is already here. I grew up around Thomas and his brother through a childhood friend and was very close to the Backus family for most of my life. I even considered some, my own family. I spent the greater part of my summers and weekends on Polly Miller Road from the age of 8 until around 18. we would help the local farmers bale hay, we would camp, fish the creek, ride bikes, fool around in the wood’s etc. First of all there was no burning due to “witchcraft” and no such thing as the chair in the road. I will say this… Polly Miller road is most definitely haunted and I have personally seen and heard very, very strange things to put it mildly! It doesn’t just stop at the ghost story. Speaking of which, I can tell you with great confidence the actual story of Polly Miller as told to us by many different farmers and old timers from around the area over the years. All of their stories were the same. I have already tried researching this with the Town of Columbia and Herkimer County and they have very little information to offer. With that being said, here is the “old timer” story of Polly Miller. Polly Miller was married to a local architect. Her husband left town to help on a project either in Albany or Amsterdam for several weeks. Upon his return it was found that Polly had been cheating on him. He ended up poisoning her and burning down the house with her body in it. That is the official story from the old timers that had been passed down through generations that lived there. While I can not claim that I have ever actually seen a *boop,boop here I am* ghost on any property, I can tell you that it is a very, very strange area, and there was rarely a weekend that went by without something very bizarre happening.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *